|
I think that an actual rating system is the way to go - there are just too many addons out there, and a lot that seem to just be poorly made/rarely updated, etc.
What about a system where you can either give an addon a + or a - rating.
The effect on the overall rating of that addon would be based on your own 'rank', which is determined by the number of posts in the forum you have and/or the average ratings of your own addons, number of different addon downloads, etc. Unregistered users would not be able to rank any addons.
My thinking is that a user like Tekkub, who would probably have a very, very high rating, if they rate an addon as good, it should mean more than some random user who's only ever downloaded one other addon, and has never posted on the forums.
__________________
|